Crumbl Cookies has grown into a well-known name, thanks to its pink box, rotating menu, and the way people enjoy sharing their experiences online. The brand brings a sense of fun to dessert runs, and many fans look forward to checking what’s new each week. With so many flavors released over time, conversations about the most liked ones have become a common part of the Crumbl experience.
This article focuses on that interest by highlighting flavors that often come up when people talk about their favorites. It gives readers a simple starting point as they look through the many options the bakery has offered. Whether someone buys Crumbl often or only now and then, this overview helps set the tone for a friendly look at the flavors that tend to draw the most attention.
#20 – Chocolate Peanut Butter ft. Oreo
Chocolate Peanut Butter ft. Oreo combines a soft chocolate cookie base with pieces of Oreo cookies and peanut butter chips. The cookie is topped with a creamy peanut butter mousse and finished with a mini Oreo, giving it a mix of textures that many fans enjoy. The combination of chocolate, peanut butter, and Oreo creates a sweet, familiar flavor that stands out on Crumbl’s rotating menu.
People who try this flavor often appreciate the balance between the chewy cookie and the crunchy Oreo pieces. The peanut butter mousse adds richness without overpowering the chocolate, making it a popular choice for those looking for a cookie that feels fun and satisfying. Many Crumbl customers say it’s a go-to flavor when they want a classic combination with a playful twist.
#19 – Churro
Churro from Crumbl is a cinnamon cookie coated in a cinnamon-sugar blend for a sweet and slightly crunchy exterior. A swirl of cinnamon buttercream on top adds a soft, creamy layer, making the cookie flavorful and enjoyable. The combination of warm cinnamon and sweet frosting gives a familiar taste that many people recognize and like.
Fans of this flavor often mention how the soft cookie and sugar coating work together to create a comforting treat. The gentle spice and creamy topping make it a choice that appeals to those looking for a simple but satisfying dessert. Its popularity has helped it appear repeatedly on Crumbl’s rotating menu, showing that it resonates with many customers.
#18 – Raspberry Cheesecake Cookie
Raspberry Cheesecake Cookie from Crumbl features a graham cracker–style cookie base that is soft in the center with a subtle crunch on the edges. It is topped with a smooth vanilla cheesecake frosting that mimics the texture of classic cheesecake. A swirl of raspberry jam adds a bright, fruity contrast, creating a combination of sweet and tangy flavors that many fans enjoy.
Many people appreciate how the tartness of the raspberry balances the rich vanilla cheesecake frosting. This flavor is often mentioned as a favorite for those who enjoy cheesecake in a portable, cookie form. Its recurring presence on the Crumbl menu shows it has become a popular choice among regular customers and those new to the bakery alike.
#17 – Honey Cake ft. Teddy Grahams
Honey Cake ft. Teddy Grahams is a graham-style cookie with a soft, slightly crumbly base that reminds many people of classic graham cracker flavor. It is topped with honey butter frosting and a light drizzle of honey. Two small bear-shaped Teddy Grahams on top add a playful, nostalgic touch. The combination of the graham base, sweet frosting, and crunchy Teddy Grahams creates a familiar and fun cookie experience.
Fans of this flavor often note that it is sweet without being overwhelming. The honey and frosting add richness while letting the graham flavor shine. The Teddy Grahams on top bring a comforting, childhood-snack feeling. Its mix of flavors and textures has made it a popular choice whenever it appears on Crumbl’s rotating menu.
#16 – Ultimate Peanut Butter
Ultimate Peanut Butter from Crumbl features a peanut butter cookie base that is soft and chewy, often filled with extra peanut butter inside. The cookie is rolled in sugar before baking and finished with a light drizzle of peanut butter on top. Each bite delivers a strong, nutty flavor that appeals to fans of classic peanut butter desserts.
Many people enjoy this cookie for its consistent, full-flavored peanut butter taste. The combination of the chewy center, sugar-coated exterior, and topping makes it a popular choice for those who like a straightforward but satisfying cookie. While it is rich and intense, fans say that it perfectly captures the peanut butter flavor they love.
#15 – S’mores
S’mores from Crumbl begins with a soft graham‑cracker style cookie base filled with milk chocolate chips. On top sits a toasted marshmallow‑style topping plus melted chocolate and a sprinkle of graham cracker crumbs to give a nod to the classic campfire treat. The mix of a buttery cookie base, gooey marshmallow, and smooth chocolate aims to recreate the familiar taste many people remember from actual s’mores.
People who try this flavor often praise the warm, cozy feeling it offers. The marshmallow and chocolate bring sweetness and richness while the graham base adds a slightly toasty flavor that balances it out. For fans of s’mores or anyone seeking a dessert that’s a little nostalgic yet still full of chocolatey comfort, this cookie tends to be a go‑to favorite from Crumbl’s lineup.
#14 – Maple Bacon
Maple Bacon from Crumbl features a soft buttermilk-style cookie base topped with thick maple frosting, a drizzle of maple syrup, and a sprinkle of real bacon bits. The sweet maple frosting and syrup provide a rich sweetness while the bacon adds a salty crunch. The combination creates a unique flavor that blends dessert and breakfast elements.
Fans of this flavor often note how the salty bacon balances the sweetness of the maple. The contrast between the soft cookie, sticky frosting, and crunchy bacon makes it a standout option on Crumbl’s rotating menu. While very sweet, many people enjoy it as a fun and unexpected take on a classic breakfast combination.
#13 – Birthday Cake ft. Oreo
Birthday Cake ft. OREO begins with a chocolate-cookie base packed with pieces of OREO cookies. On top sits a layer of cake-batter cream-cheese frosting that adds a sweet and slightly creamy feel. The cookie is finished with extra OREO bits and rainbow sprinkles for a festive, celebratory look and added texture.
This flavor works well for those who love a mix of classic OREO crunch and sweet frosting. The contrast between the firm cookie base and the soft frosting makes each bite feel rich and fun. When this flavor appears in Crumbl’s weekly lineup, it often draws attention from regular customers and first-time buyers alike.
#12 – Blue Monster ft. Chips Ahoy!
Blue Monster ft. Chips Ahoy! from Crumbl features a brown-sugar and semi-sweet chocolate chip cookie base rolled in chopped Chips Ahoy! pieces before baking. It is topped with smooth blue vanilla frosting and finished with a mini Chips Ahoy! cookie. The combination blends classic chocolate chip cookie flavor with a fun and colorful frosting twist.
Fans enjoy how the cookie captures the familiar taste of a Chips Ahoy! while adding the softness and texture of Crumbl’s bakery-style dough. The mix of crunchy cookie pieces and creamy frosting gives each bite a playful contrast. This flavor is popular among those who like cookies with added texture and sweetness.
#11 – Sea Salt Toffee
Sea Salt Toffee from Crumbl is built on a soft, toffee‑infused cookie base that brings a rich, buttery caramel taste paired with chewy texture. Embedded in the dough are toffee pieces and milk‑chocolate chips that add sweetness and a little bit of crunch. A light sprinkle of sea salt helps balance the sweetness so the flavor does not get too heavy.
For many fans this cookie hits a satisfying sweet‑and‑salty balance. The toffee pieces and chocolate chips give texture, while the gentle pinch of salt lifts the flavor so each bite feels balanced rather than overly sweet. Because it repeats often on the menu, this flavor remains a reliable pick for those who enjoy a cookie that mixes caramel‑sweet notes and subtle salt for a classic treat.
#10 – Nilla Bean Cupcake
Nilla Bean Cupcake features a soft, cake-like vanilla bean cookie base that offers a warm and comforting flavor. It is topped with creamy vanilla cream cheese frosting and finished with a sprinkle of white confetti sprinkles. The vanilla bean flavor runs through both the cookie and frosting, creating a consistent, sweet, and mild taste that many fans enjoy.
This flavor is popular for its gentle sweetness and soft texture. The frosting adds a smooth, creamy layer that complements the vanilla base. For those who prefer simple and sweet cookies rather than bold or experimental flavors, Nilla Bean Cupcake provides a comforting option that feels slightly more special than a standard sugar cookie.
#9 – Key Lime Pie Cookie
Key Lime Pie Cookie from Crumbl features a graham-cracker cookie base that is buttery with a slight crunch. The cookie is topped with a smooth lime-flavored filling, whipped cream, graham cracker crumbs, and a small lime slice for a fresh touch. The combination offers a balance of tangy lime and sweet crust, creating a dessert that feels like a mini key lime pie in cookie form.
The bright lime flavor contrasts with the sweet cookie base, making it a popular choice for those who want something different from traditional chocolate or buttery cookies. Its soft texture and fresh flavor make it a standout option on Crumbl’s rotating menu.
#8 – Buckeye Brownie
Buckeye Brownie from Crumbl features a dense chocolate brownie-style cookie filled with creamy peanut butter and topped with melted chocolate. Each bite delivers a mix of rich chocolate and nutty peanut butter, creating a flavor combination that fans often enjoy. The cookie brings sweetness and chocolate flavor together in a way that is both satisfying and memorable.
Many people like Buckeye Brownie for its chocolate-and-peanut-butter combination in a soft, chewy cookie form. The fudgy texture of the base pairs well with the smooth peanut butter and chocolate topping, creating a layered dessert experience. Its consistent popularity shows that it remains a favorite whenever it appears on Crumbl’s weekly menu.
#7 – Kentucky Butter Cake
Kentucky Butter Cake from Crumbl features a yellow butter-cake style cookie base that is soft and cake-like. After baking, it is coated with a buttery glaze and finished with a light dusting of powdered sugar, adding a subtle sweetness and gentle texture on top. The combination of soft cookie, buttery glaze, and powdered sugar creates a simple, comforting treat.
Fans enjoy Kentucky Butter Cake for its warmth and homey flavor. Serving it slightly warm brings out the buttery glaze and enhances the soft texture. Its classic taste and delicate sugar topping make it a cookie that many return to again and again.
#6 – Snickerdoodle Cupcake
Snickerdoodle Cupcake from Crumbl starts with a soft, cinnamon-sugar cookie base that has a gentle crisp along the edges. The cookie is topped with a generous swirl of cream cheese frosting, finished with an extra sprinkle of cinnamon sugar. The mix of spiced cookie and creamy frosting creates a comforting flavor that is familiar yet satisfying. Each bite brings the warmth of cinnamon with a smooth sweetness from the frosting, giving fans a sense of classic dessert nostalgia in cookie form.
Many people enjoy Snickerdoodle Cupcake because it balances flavor and texture so well. The soft cookie base contrasts with the creamy frosting and slight crisp of the sugar topping. It is often chosen by those who prefer a cookie that is sweet but not overwhelming, with a cozy, homey feel. Its combination of spice and cream makes it a standout among Crumbl’s rotating menu options.
#5 – Brownie Batter
Brownie Batter from Crumbl features a chocolate cookie base packed with semi-sweet chocolate chips. On top, a layer of brownie batter adds a soft, fudgy center and a slightly cracked chocolate surface. Each bite delivers a rich chocolate flavor with a chewy and moist texture that echoes freshly baked brownies.
The mix of cookie and brownie batter creates a dessert that is sweet and satisfying, with chocolate chips adding bursts of extra flavor. This cookie is perfect for anyone who enjoys a deep chocolate taste combined with a soft texture. Its rich flavor and gooey consistency make it stand out on Crumbl’s rotating menu. Brownie Batter remains a favorite for chocolate lovers looking for a treat that brings the classic experience of homemade brownies in cookie form.
#4 – Cookies & Cream Milkshake
Cookies & Cream Milkshake from Crumbl starts with a cookie base mixed with pieces of Oreo cookies. It is topped with smooth vanilla buttercream that also includes Oreo crumbs. A mini Oreo on top adds a final crunchy touch. The cookie is often served chilled, giving it a cool, refreshing finish that echoes the taste of a classic cookies-and-cream milkshake.
The combination of Oreo pieces in the cookie and frosting creates a satisfying contrast of crunchy bits and creamy sweetness. The chilled buttercream adds a smooth texture that complements the soft cookie base. This flavor appeals to those who enjoy cookies and cream desserts or want a sweet treat with a refreshing twist. Its playful take on a familiar flavor keeps it popular whenever it appears on Crumbl’s rotating menu.
#3 – Cookie Dough
Cookie Dough from Crumbl features a soft brown-sugar cookie base that offers a sweet, slightly caramel-like flavor. On top, it is layered with creamy cookie-dough buttercream frosting and chunks of edible cookie dough. The combination delivers the classic taste of raw cookie dough with the comfort and texture of a baked cookie.
The cookie offers a balance of textures, with the soft base, smooth frosting, and chewy dough pieces creating a satisfying bite. Its sweet and doughy flavor sets it apart from more traditional chocolate or fruit-based cookies. Cookie Dough continues to be a standout option in Crumbl’s weekly rotation, appealing to those who enjoy the playful, nostalgic experience of cookie dough in every bite. Its mix of textures and flavors makes it a favorite among both new and returning fans.
#2 – Classic Pink Sugar
Classic Pink Sugar starts with a soft vanilla‑sugar cookie base that bakes up tender and slightly chewy, with just a hint of crisp at the edges. On top sits a smooth pink frosting flavored with almond extract. The frosting brings a sweet, slightly nutty note that pairs well with the gentle cookie base. The pastel pink frosting and simple sugar‑cookie base make this treat feel cheerful and easy to enjoy.
This cookie remains popular because it offers a straightforward, comforting flavor rather than heavy toppings or extra layers. Its balance of soft cookie and creamy frosting makes it a go-to when you want something sweet but mild. Classic Pink Sugar has become one of Crumbl’s signature flavors, and many return to it when it appears on the rotating menu.
#1 – Milk Chocolate Chip
Milk Chocolate Chip from Crumbl features a soft, buttery cookie base made with vanilla and brown sugar that creates a warm, slightly sweet dough flavor. Large milk chocolate chips are mixed throughout, giving each bite smooth, creamy chocolate that melts into the cookie. The cookie bakes with a slightly crisp edge and a soft, chewy center, highlighting the sweet chocolate without being overwhelming.
This flavor offers a classic chocolate chip experience enhanced for a bakery-style treat. Its gentle sweetness, soft texture, and large serving size make it ideal for sharing or enjoying as a comforting snack. Milk Chocolate Chip remains one of the most popular flavors on Crumbl’s rotating menu because it delivers a familiar taste and consistent quality that appeals to chocolate lovers of all ages.
