Coffee Mate Just Launched 2 New, Limited-Edition Creamers Fans Begged For

There are plenty of great coffee creamers out there competing for a place in our cups—Chobani, Califia Farms, even Trader Joe’s have all stepped up their game. But Coffee mate will always stand apart for one reason: its flavors. No other brand is quite as daring or imaginative as America’s number one creamer. From summer-inspired drops to soda-flavored creations, Coffee mate has never been afraid to take risks—and that’s exactly what keeps coffee fans coming back. 

In this year’s holiday lineup, you won’t just find another Peppermint Mocha or Sugar Cookie flavor. Coffee mate is introducing something completely unexpected—and something that’s never been done before.

Coffee Mate x Harry Potter’s New Butterbeer Creamer and Cold Foam Creamer

Earlier this year, Coffee mate introduced two Harry Potter–inspired flavors: Toffee Cauldron Cake and Zero Sugar White Chocolate Peppermint Toad. Harry Potter fans loved the unexpected collab, but immediately noticed something missing.

“Why is there no butterbeer flavor? Like, c’mon man, it’s the main flavor!” one fan complained. “Not having a butterbeer flavor is a crime,” another added. 

They had a point. 2025 has practically become the year of Butterbeer, with launches like Butterbeer Hershey’s Kisses, Goldfish Butterbeer Grahams, Keebler Butterbeer Fudge Stripes Cookies, and even a Butterscotch Icee debuting at Regal theaters. So, the omission was obvious, and fan requests kept coming in.

According to one brand study, 72 percent of Harry Potter fans said they wanted more flavors from the Coffee mate and Warner Bros. collab—specifically, the signature drink of the Wizarding World. After all, the creamy, butterscotch-caramel flavor feels like coffee’s perfect companion.

So, now, for its second spellbinding collab of 2025, Coffee mate is finally giving fans what they’ve been asking for: Butterbeer Creamer. The first-of-its-kind flavor lineup includes three varieties—regular, Zero Sugar, and Cold Foam—all featuring a blend of sweet butterscotch, rich cream flavor, and a touch of caramel.

For any Potterhead who’s dreamed of tasting the frothy, fantastical beverage in coffee form, here’s your chance. It might not be a pint from The Three Broomsticks, but it’s almost guaranteed to make mornings feel a little more magical—especially during the cozy season, when the beloved book series really shines.

The new Butterbeer creamers will begin rolling out at U.S. retailers in December, followed by a nationwide launch in January. The classic creamers will retail for $4.49 for a 28-ounce creamer bottle, while the Cold Foam version will sell for $5.49 in a 14-ounce canister.

This new flavor completes a magical trio of Harry Potter creamers ready to enchant your morning brew. Whether you’re craving the sweetness of Honeydukes or the cheery comfort of Butterbeer, only Coffee mate could capture the taste of the Wizarding World in a mug, and we couldn’t be more excited to try it.